MortgageLoans.net

Debt-to-Income Ratio Explained (DTI)

The debt-to-income ratio (DTI) is a percentage that compares a borrower's total recurring monthly debt payments to gross monthly income. Lenders use front-end DTI (housing costs only) and back-end DTI (all debts) to evaluate whether a borrower can sustain a mortgage payment. Maximum DTI limits vary by loan program and may be adjusted by compensating factors.

Key Takeaways

  • Front-end DTI measures housing costs as a percentage of gross monthly income; back-end DTI includes all recurring debts
  • Conventional loans typically allow a maximum back-end DTI of 45% with strong credit, or up to 50% with automated underwriting approval and compensating factors
  • FHA loans permit a back-end DTI of up to 57% in some cases with automated underwriting system approval
  • Debts with fewer than 10 months of remaining payments may be excluded from DTI under certain loan programs
  • DTI is calculated using gross income before taxes, not take-home pay
  • Compensating factors such as large cash reserves, minimal payment shock, or a strong credit history can offset a higher DTI

How It Works

Front-End DTI (Housing Ratio)

The front-end ratio includes the total proposed monthly housing expense: principal and interest on the mortgage, real estate taxes, homeowner’s insurance, mortgage insurance (if applicable), and homeowner’s association dues. For FHA loans, the standard front-end DTI limit is 31%, though automated underwriting may approve ratios above this threshold. Conventional loans under Fannie Mae guidelines do not enforce a hard front-end limit when the loan is approved through Desktop Underwriter (DU), though manually underwritten conventional loans typically cap the front-end ratio at 28%. VA loans do not use a front-end ratio and instead rely on a residual income test alongside the back-end DTI.

Back-End DTI (Total Debt Ratio)

The back-end ratio adds all recurring monthly debt obligations to the housing expense. Qualifying debts include minimum monthly payments on credit cards, auto loans, student loans, personal loans, child support, alimony, and any other installment or revolving accounts appearing on the credit report. The back-end ratio is the primary gatekeeper in most loan programs. Conventional loans under Fannie Mae guidelines generally allow a maximum back-end DTI of 45%, with DU approvals permitting up to 50% when the borrower has strong compensating factors such as high credit scores and significant reserves. FHA’s automated underwriting system (TOTAL Scorecard) may approve borrowers with back-end DTIs up to 57%, though manual underwriting caps FHA at 43% without compensating factors or 50% with specific compensating factors.

What Counts as Debt

Lenders include the following in the back-end DTI: minimum credit card payments (even if the borrower pays in full monthly), auto loan and lease payments, student loan payments (using actual payment, IBR payment, or a percentage of the balance depending on the program), personal and installment loan payments, child support and alimony obligations, co-signed loan payments unless the primary borrower can demonstrate 12 months of independent payment history, and any other accounts with required monthly payments reported on the credit report. Debts with 10 or fewer remaining payments may be excluded from DTI for conventional loans if the payments do not significantly affect the borrower’s ability to repay. Utilities, insurance premiums (other than mortgage-related), groceries, cell phone bills, and subscriptions are not included in DTI.

Income Used in DTI

The denominator in the DTI calculation is the borrower’s gross monthly income, meaning income before federal and state taxes, Social Security contributions, and other payroll deductions. Gross income includes base salary, documented overtime, bonus and commission income (averaged over the applicable period), self-employment income (as calculated from tax returns), rental income (net of vacancy and PITIA offsets), retirement and pension income, Social Security benefits, disability income, and other qualifying income sources. Each income type has its own documentation and continuity requirements. Part-time or seasonal income must be documented for a minimum period, typically two years, to be included.

Compensating Factors

When a borrower’s DTI exceeds standard limits, compensating factors may allow approval at higher ratios. Common compensating factors include: significant cash reserves (typically three or more months of total housing payments), minimal increase in housing payment compared to current rent or mortgage (low payment shock), a credit score significantly above the program minimum, a long and stable employment history, the borrower making a larger down payment than required, and documented energy-efficient home features that reduce utility costs. Compensating factors are evaluated in combination, and the presence of multiple strong factors provides greater flexibility than any single factor alone.

Related topics include mortgage lenders calculate income, self-employed income calculation, variable income averaging (overtime, bonus, commission), rental income for mortgage qualification, asset and reserve requirements explained, and common income mistakes that cause mortgage denials.

Key Factors

Factors relevant to Debt-to-Income Ratio Explained (DTI)
Factor Description Typical Range
Front-End Ratio (Housing) Proposed housing payment (PITIA) divided by gross monthly income; used primarily in FHA and manual underwriting 28% conventional manual / 31% FHA standard
Back-End Ratio (Total Debt) All recurring monthly debts plus proposed housing payment divided by gross monthly income 43-50% conventional / 43-57% FHA depending on underwriting method
Loan Program Limits Each loan program (conventional, FHA, VA, USDA) has its own DTI thresholds and exceptions VA uses 41% guideline with residual income override; USDA cap is 41% back-end
Compensating Factors Borrower strengths that allow underwriters or automated systems to approve higher DTI ratios Each factor can extend DTI limits by 1-7 percentage points depending on program
Student Loan Payment Calculation Method used to determine the monthly payment included in DTI when actual payment is $0 or income-driven 0.5% of balance (Fannie Mae) / 1% of balance or actual IBR (FHA)
Remaining Payment Exclusion Debts with 10 or fewer remaining payments may be excluded from DTI for certain loan programs 10 months or fewer for conventional; FHA does not permit this exclusion

Examples

Conventional Loan DTI Calculation with Standard Debts

Scenario: A borrower earns $8,000 per month gross income. The proposed housing payment (PITIA) is $2,000. Other monthly debts include: $400 auto loan, $150 student loan payment, and $100 in minimum credit card payments. Total monthly debts including housing: $2,650.
Outcome: Front-end DTI: $2,000 / $8,000 = 25%. Back-end DTI: $2,650 / $8,000 = 33.1%. Both ratios are well within conventional guidelines. The borrower qualifies from a DTI perspective without the need for compensating factors.

FHA Borrower with Elevated DTI and Compensating Factors

Scenario: A borrower earns $5,500 per month gross income. The proposed FHA housing payment is $1,850. Other monthly debts total $950 (auto loan, student loans, credit cards). Total monthly debts: $2,800. The borrower has a 680 credit score, three months of reserves, and has been employed at the same company for 7 years.
Outcome: Front-end DTI: $1,850 / $5,500 = 33.6%. Back-end DTI: $2,800 / $5,500 = 50.9%. The front-end exceeds the 31% FHA guideline and the back-end exceeds 50%. FHA's automated underwriting (TOTAL Scorecard) may still approve this borrower based on the combination of compensating factors. If the system issues a Refer, manual underwriting would likely cap DTI at 43% without sufficient compensating factors, and this borrower would not qualify without reducing debts or increasing income.

Impact of Student Loan Payment Calculation Method on DTI

Scenario: A borrower has $80,000 in student loan debt on an income-driven repayment plan with a current monthly payment of $0. Gross monthly income is $6,500, and the proposed housing payment is $1,800. Other debts total $400. Under Fannie Mae guidelines, the lender must use 0.5% of the student loan balance ($400/month) as the qualifying payment. Under FHA guidelines, the lender may use the actual IBR payment of $0 if documented.
Outcome: Conventional back-end DTI: ($1,800 + $400 + $400) / $6,500 = 40%. FHA back-end DTI: ($1,800 + $400 + $0) / $6,500 = 33.8%. The student loan calculation method creates a 6.2 percentage point difference in DTI between programs. This borrower qualifies under both programs but has significantly more room under FHA guidelines due to the $0 IBR payment treatment.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Calculating DTI using net (take-home) pay instead of gross income

    DTI is always calculated using gross monthly income before taxes and deductions. A borrower who earns $6,000 gross but takes home $4,200 after deductions should use $6,000 as the denominator. Using net pay produces an inflated DTI that does not reflect how lenders will evaluate the application. This is one of the most common sources of borrower confusion when self-assessing qualification.

  • Assuming all monthly expenses are included in DTI

    Lenders include only recurring debt obligations that appear on the credit report or are otherwise documented (such as court-ordered support). Utilities, groceries, cell phone plans, streaming subscriptions, daycare costs, and general living expenses are not part of the DTI calculation. Conversely, borrowers sometimes forget that co-signed debts, authorized user accounts with balances, and deferred student loans may be included.

  • Paying off a debt with fewer than 10 remaining payments without confirming program eligibility for exclusion

    Conventional guidelines allow debts with 10 or fewer remaining monthly payments to be excluded from DTI. However, FHA does not permit this exclusion regardless of remaining term. Borrowers who pay down a debt to reduce their payment count may find the strategy works for a conventional loan but not for an FHA application. Additionally, even under conventional guidelines, the payments must not be significant relative to the borrower's income to qualify for exclusion.

  • Opening new credit accounts or making large purchases between pre-approval and closing

    Lenders pull credit again before closing and recalculate DTI. A new car loan, furniture financing, or credit card balance increase after pre-approval can push DTI above program limits, resulting in a last-minute denial or loan condition. Borrowers should avoid any new credit activity from the time of application through closing.

Documents You May Need

  • Recent pay stubs covering the most recent 30-day period
  • Two years of W-2 forms from all employers
  • Two years of federal tax returns with all schedules (if self-employed or receiving variable income)
  • Most recent statements for all credit card, loan, and revolving accounts
  • Divorce decree or separation agreement documenting alimony or child support obligations
  • Student loan statements showing current repayment plan and monthly payment amount
  • Documentation of any co-signed loan payment history (12 months of cancelled checks or bank statements)

Frequently Asked Questions

Does my car insurance payment count toward DTI?
No. Auto insurance, health insurance, life insurance, and other insurance premiums (except mortgage-related insurance like PMI and homeowner's insurance included in PITIA) are not recurring debt obligations and are excluded from DTI. Only debts that appear on your credit report or are court-ordered obligations are included in the calculation.
How are credit card minimum payments calculated for DTI if I pay my balance in full each month?
Lenders use the minimum payment shown on your most recent credit report or statement, regardless of your actual payment habits. If your credit card reports a $10,000 balance and a $200 minimum payment, the $200 is included in your DTI even if you pay the full $10,000 every month. Paying down balances before application can reduce the reported minimum payment and lower your DTI.
Can I reduce my DTI by paying off debts before closing?
Yes, but the lender must verify the payoff. If you pay off a debt to improve DTI, the lender will require evidence of payoff (such as a zero-balance statement or payoff confirmation letter) and will verify that the funds used for payoff are sourced and seasoned. The lender will also confirm that the payoff does not reduce your cash reserves below the minimum required for the loan program.
Does a lease on my current apartment count toward DTI?
Your current rent payment is not included in the DTI calculation for a purchase mortgage because it will be replaced by the new housing payment. However, if you will continue renting a property (for example, you own a home and also rent a separate office space under a personal lease), that obligation would be included. For refinances, your current mortgage payment is replaced by the proposed new payment in the DTI calculation.
What is the difference between DTI limits for automated versus manual underwriting?
Automated underwriting systems (like Fannie Mae's Desktop Underwriter or FHA's TOTAL Scorecard) evaluate the entire borrower profile holistically and can approve loans at higher DTI ratios than manual underwriting allows. A conventional loan manually underwritten is typically limited to 36-43% back-end DTI depending on compensating factors, while DU may approve up to 50%. FHA manual underwriting caps at 43% without compensating factors or 50% with them, while the TOTAL Scorecard may approve up to 57%.
Does my spouse's debt count if they are not on the loan?
In most states, a non-borrowing spouse's debts are not included in DTI. However, in community property states (Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin), debts incurred by either spouse during the marriage may be included in the borrower's DTI even if the spouse is not on the loan application. Lenders in community property states will typically pull credit on the non-borrowing spouse to identify community debts.
Last updated: Reviewed by:

Related Topics