How DSCR Underwriting Evaluates a Loan
DSCR underwriting centers on three pillars: the property’s income performance, the borrower’s creditworthiness, and the equity position (LTV). Unlike conventional underwriting, which adds a fourth pillar of personal income verification, DSCR removes that component entirely and places greater weight on the property’s demonstrated or projected ability to service the debt.
The process begins with the borrower submitting a loan application that includes the property details, requested loan amount, and credit authorization. The lender pulls the borrower’s credit report and evaluates the credit score, credit history, and any derogatory events. Simultaneously, the lender orders an appraisal that includes a rental income analysis. For long-term rental properties, the appraiser provides a market rent opinion based on comparable rental properties. For short-term rentals, some lenders accept third-party rental projection reports from platforms that analyze historical booking data for similar properties in the same market.
Once the appraisal and rent analysis are complete, the lender calculates the DSCR by dividing the documented rental income by the projected PITIA based on the proposed loan terms. If the DSCR meets the lender’s minimum threshold and the borrower’s credit score and LTV fall within acceptable parameters, the loan moves to approval. If the DSCR falls below the threshold, the borrower may need to increase the down payment (which reduces the monthly payment and improves the DSCR), negotiate a lower purchase price, or demonstrate that the property can command higher rent than the appraiser estimated.
How Rental Income Is Documented for DSCR
DSCR lenders accept several forms of rental income documentation depending on the property’s current status. For properties with existing tenants, the executed lease agreement is the primary document. The lender verifies the lease terms, the tenant’s occupancy, and the rent amount. Some lenders require evidence that the tenant has been paying rent consistently, such as bank deposit records or a landlord verification letter from the current owner (on purchase transactions).
For properties being purchased without existing tenants, or for properties the borrower intends to rent after closing, the appraiser’s market rent opinion serves as the rental income figure for DSCR calculation. This estimate is based on comparable rental properties in the immediate area and reflects current market conditions. The lender may also accept a signed lease agreement executed between the borrower and a future tenant, even if the tenant has not yet moved in, provided the lease terms are consistent with market conditions.
For short-term rental properties (Airbnb, VRBO), lenders that accept this property type may use projected rental income from a third-party analysis such as AirDNA, Mashvisor, or a similar platform. These projections estimate annual gross income based on occupancy rates, average daily rates, and seasonal patterns for comparable properties. The lender typically applies a conservative discount to the projection to account for the variability inherent in short-term rental income .
How DSCR Loan Pricing Is Structured
DSCR loan pricing is determined by a matrix of factors that interact to produce the final interest rate. The primary pricing variables include the borrower’s credit score, the DSCR ratio, the LTV, the loan amount, the property type, the loan purpose (purchase, rate-and-term refinance, or cash-out refinance), and the prepayment penalty selection.
Each variable affects pricing independently, and the cumulative effect determines the rate. A borrower with a 740 credit score, a 1.25 DSCR, and 75% LTV on a $300,000 single-family purchase will receive meaningfully better pricing than a borrower with a 660 score, a 1.0 DSCR, and 80% LTV on the same property. The difference can be 1.0% to 2.0% in rate, translating to significant annual cost variation.
Prepayment penalty selection also affects the rate. Borrowers who accept a longer or steeper prepayment penalty structure typically receive a lower interest rate because the lender is assured the loan will remain on its books for a minimum period. Borrowers who choose a shorter prepayment period or no prepayment penalty pay a higher rate. The rate difference between a 5-year prepayment penalty and no prepayment penalty can be 0.25% to 0.75% or more .
How DSCR Loans Differ from Conventional Investment Property Financing
The fundamental difference is the income qualification method: conventional loans require full personal income documentation and calculate DTI across the borrower’s entire financial profile; DSCR loans ignore personal income and qualify the property independently. Beyond this core distinction, several practical differences affect the investor’s decision.
Conventional investment property loans are agency-backed (Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac), which provides standardized guidelines, competitive rates, and a secondary market. DSCR loans are non-QM and funded by private capital, resulting in less standardization, higher rates, and terms that vary significantly by lender. Conventional loans typically do not carry prepayment penalties; DSCR loans almost always do. Conventional loans count toward the 10-financed-property limit; DSCR loans do not, making them a critical tool for investors scaling beyond the agency cap.
For investors who qualify for conventional financing and have not reached the property count limit, conventional loans are almost always less expensive. DSCR loans become the preferred or only option when the borrower cannot document sufficient income, has exceeded the conventional property count limit, or operates through a business entity that complicates personal income documentation.
Related topics include investment property mortgage rules, hard money loans for real estate investors, portfolio loans for real estate investors, llc ownership and mortgage qualification, and short-term rental (airbnb) income for mortgages.