How Investment Property Underwriting Differs from Owner-Occupied
Investment property underwriting follows the same general framework as owner-occupied underwriting (credit evaluation, income verification, asset documentation, property appraisal) but applies stricter parameters at each stage. The underwriter evaluates the borrower’s complete real estate portfolio, not just the subject transaction. This portfolio view requires accounting for every financed property’s PITIA payment, every property’s rental income, cumulative reserve adequacy, and the borrower’s overall capacity to sustain multiple obligations under stress scenarios such as vacancy or income reduction.
The appraisal process for an investment property includes a comparable rent analysis (on Form 1007 for single-family or Form 1025 for two-to-four-unit properties) in addition to the standard value appraisal. The appraiser estimates market rent based on comparable rental properties in the area, and this figure is used in the 75% rental income offset calculation when no existing lease is available. For properties with existing leases, the underwriter compares the lease rent to the appraiser’s market rent estimate to assess reasonableness.
The income documentation burden for investment property borrowers is typically heavier than for primary residence buyers. In addition to standard income documentation (pay stubs, W-2s, tax returns), the underwriter requires Schedule E from the borrower’s tax returns for all currently owned rental properties. Schedule E shows rental income and expenses, and the underwriter calculates net rental income by adding back depreciation, non-recurring expenses, and any interest or tax deductions that are already captured in the PITIA payment to avoid double-counting .
How Rental Income Is Calculated for Qualification
The rental income calculation for investment property qualification follows a specific methodology. For properties the borrower already owns, the underwriter uses the lesser of the amount shown on Schedule E (adjusted for depreciation addback) or the amount from the lease agreement or appraisal rent analysis, multiplied by 75%. For properties being purchased, where no tax return history exists, the underwriter relies on the appraiser’s market rent estimate or the executed lease agreement, whichever is applicable, again at 75%.
If the 75% rental income exceeds the property’s PITIA, the net positive amount may be added to the borrower’s qualifying income. If the 75% rental income falls short of the PITIA, the shortfall is added to the borrower’s monthly obligations. This net approach means that a well-performing rental property can actually improve the borrower’s DTI ratio, while a property with below-market rents or a high mortgage payment can make qualification more difficult.
For borrowers with multiple rental properties, each property’s net rental contribution is calculated independently, and the total net effect across all properties is incorporated into the DTI calculation. This portfolio-level analysis can become complex when the borrower owns several properties with varying rents, vacancy situations, and mortgage payments.
How Reserve Requirements Scale with Property Count
Reserve requirements for investment property borrowers scale with the number of financed properties in the borrower’s portfolio. The base requirement is six months of PITIA for the subject investment property. Beyond the subject property, each additional financed property (whether primary residence, second home, or investment) carries its own reserve requirement. For the borrower’s primary residence and second home, the typical requirement is two months of PITIA. For each additional investment property, the requirement is typically six months of PITIA .
The cumulative reserve requirement can be a significant barrier for investors scaling a portfolio. A borrower purchasing a fifth investment property while maintaining a primary residence would need to document reserves covering six months PITIA on the new property, six months PITIA on each of the four existing investment properties, and two months PITIA on the primary residence. Depending on the values and payments involved, this could require $80,000 to $150,000 or more in liquid assets after closing.
Retirement accounts (401(k), IRA) are typically accepted as reserves at a discounted rate, usually 60% of the vested balance, to account for taxes and early withdrawal penalties. Equity in other properties is generally not accepted as reserves; the assets must be liquid or readily convertible to cash. Business accounts owned by the borrower may be acceptable if the borrower owns 100% of the business, though documentation requirements are extensive .
How the 10-Property Limit Works in Practice
The Fannie Mae 10-property limit counts all residential properties in which the borrower has a mortgage obligation, including the primary residence, any second homes, and all investment properties. Properties owned free and clear (no mortgage balance) do not count. The count includes properties where the borrower is on the mortgage note, even if the borrower is not on the property title, and properties where the borrower has a co-signed obligation.
Once a borrower reaches the limit, new conventional agency-backed financing is unavailable. Investors at or near the 10-property cap must evaluate alternative financing options including DSCR loans (which do not count conventional financed property limits because they are non-QM products), portfolio loans from community banks or credit unions that hold loans in-house, commercial loans under the borrower’s LLC or business entity, and blanket loans that cover multiple properties under a single note. Each alternative carries its own cost, structure, and qualification requirements that differ significantly from conventional agency financing.
Related topics include dscr loans explained, rental property down payment requirements, cash-out refinance on investment property, llc ownership and mortgage qualification, multi-unit property financing (2-4 units), and short-term rental (airbnb) income for mortgages.