MortgageLoans.net

What Lenders See on Your Credit Report

A mortgage credit report (tri-merge or RMCR) is a comprehensive document that combines data from all three credit bureaus and provides underwriters with a detailed view of every tradeline, payment history, public record, collection, inquiry, and personal information item in the borrower's credit file. Underwriters review this report line by line, looking well beyond the credit score itself.

Key Takeaways

  • Mortgage underwriters review the entire credit report, not just the score. Tradelines, payment history, collections, inquiries, and personal information are all examined.
  • Tradelines are categorized as revolving, installment, or mortgage. Each type is evaluated for balance, payment history, and relevance to the borrower's overall risk profile.
  • Payment history is coded by severity (30, 60, 90, 120+ days late). Recency, frequency, and severity all influence the underwriting assessment.
  • Collections appear as separate tradelines and may require payoff documentation or letters of explanation depending on the program and amount.
  • Authorized user accounts can inflate a credit profile. Underwriters may evaluate the borrower's creditworthiness with and without these accounts.
  • The inquiries section is reviewed not just for score impact but to identify potential undisclosed debts that could affect DTI.
  • Discrepancies between the credit report and the loan application generate underwriting conditions that must be resolved before closing.

How It Works

How the Tri-Merge Report Is Assembled

The mortgage tri-merge report is assembled by a credit reporting agency (CRA) that has relationships with all three national bureaus. When a lender orders the report, the CRA pulls data from Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion simultaneously and merges the results into a single formatted document. Duplicate tradelines (the same account reported by multiple bureaus) are identified and presented together so the underwriter can see any differences in how each bureau reports the account.

The CRA also generates three FICO scores using the mortgage-specific model versions (FICO 2 for Experian, FICO 5 for Equifax, FICO 4 for TransUnion). The merged report includes fraud alerts, consumer statements, and any public record entries. The cost of a tri-merge report is typically borne by the borrower as part of the application process, either as a direct fee or bundled into closing costs.

Bureau-Specific Differences in Reporting

Not all creditors report to all three bureaus. A credit card issuer may report to Equifax and Experian but not TransUnion. A small credit union may report to only one bureau. This selective reporting creates differences in the data available at each bureau, which in turn produces different FICO scores. Additionally, the timing of when creditors update their reporting can vary; one bureau may reflect a recently paid-down balance while another still shows the prior month’s higher balance.

These differences mean that a tradeline appearing as current on one bureau may show a different balance or payment status on another. Underwriters are trained to evaluate these discrepancies and determine which data is most current or accurate. When material differences exist, the underwriter may request additional documentation to reconcile the information.

What Triggers Underwriting Conditions

Underwriting conditions are requirements that the underwriter issues when the credit report raises questions or concerns. Common triggers include:

Recent late payments on any account require a letter of explanation describing the circumstances and demonstrating that the issue has been resolved. Outstanding collections above program-specific dollar thresholds may require evidence of payment or a payment arrangement . Inquiries within the past 90-120 days from lenders other than the current applicant may require confirmation that no new debt was incurred. Discrepancies between reported addresses and the application require reconciliation. Open disputes on tradelines may need to be resolved or the dispute removed before closing, depending on agency requirements.

Conditions are not denials; they are requests for additional information. Responding promptly and thoroughly to conditions is essential for keeping the loan process on track.

The Refresh Pull Before Closing

Many lenders perform a credit refresh (sometimes called a soft pull or supplement) shortly before closing to verify that the borrower’s credit profile has not materially changed since the original tri-merge was pulled. This refresh checks for new accounts, new inquiries, and significant balance changes. If the refresh reveals a new auto loan, a newly opened credit card with a large balance, or a new collection account, the loan may be delayed or denied as the lender recalculates DTI and reassesses risk.

Borrowers should avoid any credit activity between application and closing, including opening new accounts, co-signing for others, making large purchases on credit, or allowing existing accounts to go late. The pre-closing credit refresh is specifically designed to catch these changes.

Related topics include credit scores for mortgage explained (fico, vantagescore), minimum credit score requirements by loan type, credit inquiries affect your mortgage application, credit utilization and its impact on mortgage approval, late payments and mortgage qualification, and collections, judgments, and liens on mortgage applications.

Key Factors

Factors relevant to What Lenders See on Your Credit Report
Factor Description Typical Range
Tradeline Types The mix of account types (revolving, installment, mortgage) reported on the credit file. Demonstrates breadth of credit management experience. 3-5+ active tradelines across at least 2 types is generally sufficient to generate a reliable credit score and support mortgage underwriting.
Payment History Severity The degree of delinquency on any account. 30-day lates are less damaging than 60, 90, or 120-day lates. Mortgage lates carry the heaviest underwriting scrutiny. No lates is ideal. 30-day late: moderate impact. 60-day late: significant impact. 90+ day late: severe impact, especially if recent.
Collection Accounts Debts that have been sent to a collection agency. May be medical or non-medical. Treatment varies by loan program and outstanding balance. FHA requires payoff of collections above certain thresholds or inclusion in DTI. Conventional treatment varies by lender overlay .
Credit Inquiry Volume Number and recency of hard credit inquiries. Signals recent credit-seeking behavior and may indicate undisclosed new debts. 1-2 inquiries have minimal impact. 6+ inquiries in the past 12 months may raise concerns. Mortgage rate shopping inquiries are deduplicated.
Account Age and Depth The length of credit history and the number of established accounts. Thin files with few accounts or short histories may require alternative credit documentation. Average account age of 5+ years is favorable. Minimum 3 tradelines reporting for at least 12 months is a common underwriting threshold .

Examples

Undisclosed Auto Loan Discovered on Credit Report

Scenario: A borrower applies for a mortgage and does not disclose an auto loan on the application. The tri-merge credit report shows an auto installment tradeline with a $485/month payment, opened 3 months ago, with a corresponding hard inquiry from the auto lender.
Outcome: The underwriter adds the $485 monthly payment to the borrower's DTI calculation, increasing the ratio from 41% to 46%. The loan exceeds the maximum DTI of 45% for the program and is initially denied. The borrower must either pay off the auto loan, provide compensating factors to obtain a DTI exception, or reduce the mortgage amount to bring the DTI below the limit. The undisclosed liability also raises a concern about application accuracy.

Disputed Tradeline Creates Underwriting Condition

Scenario: A borrower has an outstanding dispute on a credit card account. The dispute was filed because the borrower believes a $2,400 charge was unauthorized. The credit report shows the account flagged as 'in dispute' and the balance is excluded from the FICO score calculation during the dispute period.
Outcome: The underwriter issues a condition requiring the borrower to either resolve the dispute (by removing the dispute flag) or provide a letter explaining the dispute. Under certain agency guidelines, accounts in dispute cannot be excluded from the credit evaluation, and the score may need to be recalculated without the dispute exclusion. If the recalculated score falls below the program minimum, the borrower may need to resolve the dispute before proceeding .

Authorized User Account Masking Thin Credit

Scenario: A 24-year-old borrower has two credit accounts in their own name (a credit card opened 2 years ago and a student loan opened 3 years ago) plus an authorized user account on a parent's credit card that has been open for 15 years with a perfect payment history. The authorized user account significantly boosts the average age of accounts and overall score.
Outcome: The underwriter evaluates the borrower's credit profile with and without the authorized user account. Without it, the borrower has a thin file with only 2 accounts and a short average history. The underwriter may require additional evidence that the borrower can manage credit independently, such as 12 months of rent payment verification or utility payment records. The authorized user account may remain on the report but the underwriter assesses whether the borrower's own accounts demonstrate sufficient creditworthiness.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Failing to review the full credit report before applying for a mortgage

    Borrowers who have not pulled their own credit reports may be unaware of errors, old collections, or tradelines they forgot about. Discovering these issues for the first time during underwriting causes delays and can jeopardize approval. Reviewing all three bureau reports at least 60-90 days before applying allows time to address errors and prepare explanations.

  • Not disclosing all debts on the mortgage application

    The credit report will reveal liabilities the borrower failed to disclose. Undisclosed debts increase DTI, raise questions about application accuracy, and can result in conditions, delays, or denial. Full and accurate disclosure at application is both a regulatory requirement and a practical necessity.

  • Opening disputes on tradelines shortly before or during the mortgage process

    Disputed accounts can complicate underwriting because certain scoring models exclude disputed accounts from the score calculation, creating an artificially inflated number. Lenders may require disputes to be resolved or removed before closing, which can delay the process and potentially lower the score once the dispute exclusion is lifted.

  • Making credit changes between application and closing

    The pre-closing credit refresh will detect new accounts, large balance increases, new inquiries, and late payments. Any of these changes can alter the DTI calculation, reduce the credit score, or disqualify the borrower from the approved loan terms. Maintaining credit stability from application through closing is essential.

Documents You May Need

  • Signed credit report authorization form
  • Letters of explanation for any derogatory items (late payments, collections, charge-offs, public records)
  • Documentation of payment arrangements or payoff for collection accounts (payoff letters, canceled checks)
  • Verification of alternative credit history if traditional tradelines are insufficient (rent receipts, utility bills showing 12-month payment history)
  • Evidence supporting disputed account claims (correspondence with creditors, fraud reports)
  • Recent pay stubs or bank statements to verify payment of joint debts (if claiming exclusion from DTI)

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a tri-merge credit report?
A tri-merge credit report (also called a Residential Mortgage Credit Report or RMCR) is a combined report that pulls data from all three major credit bureaus (Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion) into a single document. It includes three FICO scores using the mortgage-specific model versions, all tradelines from each bureau, payment histories, public records, collections, and inquiries. This is the standard credit report used in mortgage underwriting.
Can I see the same credit report my lender pulls?
Borrowers have the right to receive a copy of the credit report used in their mortgage application. The lender must provide this upon request. However, the tri-merge format and mortgage-specific FICO scores are not available through standard consumer channels. Consumers can access their underlying data through AnnualCreditReport.com and can purchase mortgage FICO scores through myFICO.com, but the presentation differs from the lender's merged report.
What do underwriters look for beyond the credit score?
Underwriters examine each tradeline's payment history, balances, and status. They look for derogatory marks (late payments, collections, charge-offs), undisclosed debts, recent credit activity that might affect DTI, disputed accounts, authorized user accounts that may inflate the profile, and discrepancies between the credit report and the loan application. The credit score is a summary metric; the underlying data is what drives the underwriting decision.
Why does the same account show different information at different bureaus?
Not all creditors report to all three bureaus, and those that do may report at different times during the billing cycle. This means one bureau might show a higher balance (reported before a payment posted) while another shows a lower balance (reported after the payment). Additionally, some creditors only report to one or two bureaus, so an account may appear on one report but not another.
Will the lender check my credit again before closing?
Most lenders perform a credit refresh (soft pull or supplement) shortly before closing to verify that no material changes have occurred since the original report was pulled. New accounts, large balance increases, new inquiries, or late payments discovered during this refresh can delay or derail the closing. Borrowers should avoid all credit activity between application and closing.
Last updated: Reviewed by:

Related Topics